As Yersinia pestis spread from country to country and from continent to continent, it left behind it not only a trail of death and devastation, but also a vast visual archive. For example, during the plague in Glasgow in 1901, a woman who had fallen ill with the plague was visited by two friends from Liverpool [38] (see the electronic supplementary material). The disease has recurred in Algeria [86] and Lybia [87] less than a decade ago, in places that are less than 300 miles from European boarders. This observation was later confirmed by Simond, who demonstrated in 1897 that rat-fleas were vectors for the disease [49,50]. The prevailing view among researchers in the Indo-Pacific region, including Thompson [51] who observed plague outbreaks in Sydney, Hunter who reported on plague in Hong Kong [52] and those of the Indian Plague Commission [53], was that black rats played an important role in the spread of plague, both as hosts in the chain of transmission and as carriers of the disease on ships [54]. The datasets supporting this article have been uploaded as part of the supplementary material (electronic supplementary material, table S1). Casualties from the Third Plague Pandemic dropped to fewer than 200 per year in 1960. At that time, the World Health Organization determined that the plague was no longer active. In Taranto in 1945, the allied forces, contributed noticeably to the fight against the epidemic by spraying large quantities of DDT against ‘fleas, but also bugs, lice and ticks' [66, p. 167]. Thucydides, in the History of the Peloponnesian War, paused in his narrative of the war to provide an extremely detailed description of the symptoms of those he observed to be afflicted; symptoms he shared as he too was struck by the illness. Where does human plague still persist in Latin America? Other documented sources of plague in Europe were from direct human transmission of pneumonic plague (e.g. We are now in the third pandemic (Modern Plague), with outbreaks continuing to occur in some parts of the world (14–18). Over the next few years, plague spread to many cities around the world: Bombay, Singapore, Alexandria, Buenos Aires, Rio de Janeiro, Honolulu, San Francisco and Sidney, among others [20]. China's Yunnan province was the setting for the third and last great plague pandemic, which began in the 1850s. The authors acknowledge funding from the European Research Council under the European Union's Seventh Framework Programme/ERC grant agreement (AdG MedPlag, grant agreement no. However, a similar account for Europe is missing, making it difficult to compare local and global transmission patterns. By Josh Sanburn Tuesday, Oct. 26, 2010. We review published research on previous pandemics to historicize pandemic othering and blame, and enumerate some of the consequences for politics, policy, and public health. Finally, we would like to thank three anonymous referees whose comments have improved our contribution. In late 1896, Pune was hit by bubonic plague, part of the global Third plague pandemic. However, only 60 plague-infected rats were found out of more than 266 000 rats that were caught during the 3 year survey [36,44]. The largest rat epizootic found in Marseille occurred in the poor downtown areas in 1930, where 42 infected rats were discovered out of the 7275 that were examined [64]. The earliest known European cases occurred in September and October 1896, when two sailors from Bombay died of plague on ships docked in London on the Thames [21]. However, in the years following the outbreak, they found some evidence of plague in the rat population: in 1901 (122 of 1641), in 1902 (30 of 6492) and in 1907 (1 of 140) [55]. [21,38,63]). This bubonic plague pandemic started in the Yunnan province in China. These early signs of plague included suspicion of human or rat cases onboard, as well as unexplained rat mortality [35], which was also noted in many of the case reports (electronic supplementary material, table S1). Beitrag zur Kenntnis der Verhaltensweise von Ratten vergleichend dargestellt bei, London, UK: Batsford Academic and Educational, Madrid, Spain: Comision Permanente de Investigaciones Sanitarias, Mesagne (Brindisi), Italy: Giordano Editore, Rat control in a plague outbreak in Malta, Epidemiology of a bubonic plague outbreak in Glasgow, Scotland in 1900, Between the Carlo R. and the Orleannais: public health and maritime prophylaxis in the description of two cases of ships transporting immigrants arriving in the port of Rio de Janeiro, 1893–1907, The French hygiene offensive of the 1950s: a critical moment in the history of manners, Immunity as a factor in the epidemiology of medieval plague, Metapopulation dynamics of bubonic plague, Plague persistence in western Europe: a hypothesis, Plague reappearance in Algeria after 50 years, 2003, Plague outbreak in Libya, 2009, unrelated to plague in Algeria, Globalization, international law, and emerging infectious diseases, Plague: a millenary infectious disease reemerging in the XXI century, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, http://dx.doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.c.4454687, http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/, Climate drivers of plague epidemiology in British India, 1898–1949, 1913, 1915, 1919, 1920, 1925, 1926, 1927, 1928, 1899, 1910, 1914, 1920, 1921, 1922, 1923, 1924, 1926, 1928, 1901, 1905, 1908, 1912, 1914, 1916, 1919, 1920, 1926, 1902, 1903, 1907, 1919, 1920, 1924, 1925, 1926, 1930, 1932, 1933, 1935, 1936, 1913, 1914, 1915, 1916, 1919, 1920, 1921, 1922, 1925, 1926, 1927, 1929, 1930. Two events emphasized the re-emerging threat of plague to Europe in the late 1800s. Published by the Royal Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/, which permits unrestricted use, provided the original author and source are credited. Despite the independency of these strains, the clinical symptoms were similar during the first and second pandemics. In the original reports, cases in the period before September 1927 were recorded mainly as outbreaks with start–end dates and those after September 1927 were recorded as weekly or monthly incidence. Nevertheless, over-reporting may have occurred if cases were misdiagnosed as plague. That outbreak sparked the third global plague pandemic. In bubonic plague infections, the patient’s lymph nodes swell, and the patient experiences fever, aches, and chills. See also the electronic supplementary material, table S1. Plague was notably absent in some parts of Europe. International Organization for Standardization (ISO) Country code in parentheses.). This pandemic affected the Eastern Roman Empire, specifically Constantinople and port cities along the Mediterranean sea. The two species of rats carry the same species of fleas. Photograph, 1900/1920’. The third plague pandemic was the last, for it coincided with (and in some cases motivated) a series of achievements in the scientific understanding of the disease. Plague was reported in 11 countries, and many cities, including Lisbon, Marseille, Paris and Pireas, experienced multiple outbreaks (table 1). and N.C.S. Although published in 1947 and a piece of fiction, The Plague by Albert Camus still eerily reflects how we reacted to the COVID-19 pandemic today as if it is a pattern that we need to recognize. The lack of a rodent reservoir in Europe is the fundamental reason why plague is no longer a public health threat today on the continent. It reached the Byzantine capital of Constantinople in 541 A.D., and was soon claiming up to 10,000 lives per day—so many that unburied bodies were eventually stacked inside buildings or left in the open. This article explores how plague—as an idea—became an ahistorical independent agent of historical change. Bubonic plague symptoms and signs include painful and enlarged or swollen lymph nodes (an enlarged lymph node due to plague is called a bubo), chills, ... causing the death of 60% of the entire population. The third pandemic of plague (in its bubonic and pneumonic clinical forms) struck the globe between 1894 and 1959. Here, we investigate plague during the Third Pandemic in Europe, as it differs from other parts of the world, in order to characterize the unique epidemiology of the disease during this time period. Electronic supplementary material is available online at http://dx.doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.c.4454687. There were 1692 cases and 457 deaths from plague reported in Europe between 1899 and 1947 (figure 1; electronic supplementary material, table S1), with the largest number of cases in the years 1899 and 1920. CC BY 4.0. 1–2]. The third plague pandemic that started in 1855 in China. It may have been an early appearance of smallpox that began with the Huns.The Huns then infected the Germans, who passed it to the Romans and then returning troops spread it throughout the Roman empire. Vaccination, if available, and herd immunity can curb the spread of disease. Scheube wrote that, ‘The development and spread of plague is influenced in a great measure by the unfavorable hygienic conditions, essentially connected with social misery’ [75, p. 12]. It is possible that future ancient DNA studies will demonstrate that all of the different lineages of Y. pestis involved in historic outbreaks went extinct after their introduction into Europe (see also Namouchi et al. Yet, Europe still experienced plague outbreaks during the Third Pandemic, which began in China and spread globally at the end of the nineteenth century. Thus, having documented outbreaks of the Third Pandemic can enable comparisons with historical ones, especially considering that the Third Pandemic in Europe was restricted to the pre-antibiotic era. The pandemic is believed to have originated in Africa and then spread to Europe through infected rats on merchant ships. Today, the spillover of plague from these reservoirs leads to the thousands of cases of plague reported every decade [85]. foci and reservoirs) to the rest of the world in a short time [88]. It was noted by Proust that, ‘As in the previous meeting about cholera, it was decided that the treatment applicable to ships must be regulated by their sanitary condition at the arrival and not by the state of the port of provenance which gives only indications, which may be valuable indications but which are only indications. Indeed, the Black Death was rather a word coined to refer to plague epidemics in the symbolic register (with a negative connotation) than a denomination used by Second plague pandemic and Third plague pandemic are connected through Timeline of plague, Pneumonic plague, Plague of Justinian and more.. People infected with the plague usually develop flu-like symptoms two to six days after infection. Some regions, such as the Nordics and Eastern Europe, did not report any case of plague. [36,63,64,67,74]), often in the poorest quarters of cities, where the majority of cases were found during outbreaks such as Oporto (1899), Glasgow (1900) and Marseille (1900–1921). The recommendations of the conference to governments resulted in a complex system of regulations that controlled carriers coming by land and sea from infected regions [21]. Overall, the connection between urban rodents and human plague in Europe during the Third Pandemic is less clear than for outbreaks in India and China [21,46,48–50,54,75–78]. Another key international plague conference was held in Shenyang (old name, Mukden) in April 1911, with epidemiologists and scientists from 11 countries (China, Japan, USA, Great Britain, France, Germany, Italy, Austria–Hungary, The Netherlands, Russia and Mexico) [33]. Credit: Wellcome Collection. CC BY 4.0.Download figureOpen in new tabDownload powerPoint. For instance, the Nordic countries, which reported infectious diseases such as polio and cholera, did not report any plague case during the Third Pandemic. We used narrative and scientific reports in four languages (English, French, Italian and German) to supplement the case data. Here, we compile the reported plague cases for Europe during the Third Pandemic from digitized records of notifiable diseases, previous studies and grey literature. We are thankful to Sari C. Cunningham for her editorial work. The European sanitary authorities responded by meeting often to discuss preventative measures against plague and other diseases. The second event was the discovery of two sailors from Bombay who died of plague on a ship in London in 1896 [21,32]. These reports are translated and summarized in the electronic supplementary material. Liverpool, England. In the 1910s, there was another outbreak of plague … There are other symptoms that can help distinguish the three forms of the plague. Infectiousness of any disease is measured by the reproduction number (R0, or. In many places in Europe, this work included the destruction of slums, improvement of sewage systems and the widespread development of safe water supply systems [79]. Three commissions were sent to nearby Astrakhan by European governments (French, British and joint Austrian–German) to study the outbreak which resulted in more than 400 cases [21,27–31]. This is the new principle underlying modern international prophylaxis' [21, p. vi]. 336564 (PI Christos Lynteris, University of St Andrews). Liverpool, England. especially those outbreaks associated with the second pandemic (14th to 19th centuries) in Europe and Asia (1, 3–5), and have inspired many theoretical studies of the ecology and evolution of infectious disease (6–13). [36,39,43,63–68,70]). Reported suspected plague cases per year in Europe (1899–1950) from the Public Health Reports. The American zoologist Davis [56] described similar differences in articles from the mid-1950s. collected data and performed analyses; B.B. For instance, the last outbreak in Taranto in 1945, with 30 cases and 15 deaths, was hidden owing to military reasons, and possibly, other cases were not reported in times of war. These reports show that plague was continually introduced to European ports throughout the Third Pandemic by ships arriving from abroad, often from the former European colonies such as Bombay, Buenos Aires and Alexandria (electronic supplementary material, table S1). Introductions of plague during the Third Pandemic led to the formation of plague reservoirs in the USA [22,23], South America (Peru, Bolivia and Brazil) [23,24] and Africa (Democratic Republic of the Congo, Tanzania, Uganda and Madagascar) [23,25], where ecological conditions have favoured the persistence of the bacteria in sylvatic rodent communities. Plague is not a disease that is found in Europe today, and we found no mention of plague outbreaks after 1950. Swollen and painful lymph nodes occur in the area closest to where the bacteria entered the skin. Of these, 60% were R. norvegicus and 40% were R. rattus in the docks, while all of the rats in the city were black rats. Epidemiology is the branch of medicine that handles the following: Two measurable factors mostly define the level of disease occurrence: As human civilizations rose, these pandemic diseases, from the bubonic plague to smallpox to influenza, struck them down. In addition to rats, the authorities found some ferrets, cats and rabbits that died of plague [44]. 324249, PI, BB. Il minamento della Rada di Mar Grande (1943) e l'episodio epidemico di peste bubbonica (1945), Control of plague in Taranto, Italy, 1945/1946: an account of a successful programme of rodent extermination, The last epidemic of plague in England? The Third Cholera Pandemic (1852-1860) Death Toll: Approximately 1 million Cause: Cholera According to the WHO, there have been seven cholera epidemics. The Third Pandemic of 1894 . Recent outbreaks of plague in Liverpool and Glasgow, Taranto fra guerra e dopoguerra. For plague, detailed records of cases and deaths appear in the Public Health Reports beginning in 1899 (electronic supplementary material, table S1). ‘Liverpool Port Sanitary Authority rat-catchers dipping rats in buckets of petrol to kill fleas for plague control. For some of the early outbreaks, such as those in Porto (1899) and Glasgow (1900), the cases are more temporally resolved. Although plague is no longer a public health issue in Europe today, the threat of the disease remains close in both space and time. Case records and outbreak reports for the Third Pandemic are numerous and have improved our understanding of the historical epidemiology and distribution of plague. We declare we have no competing interests. Minor role in plague transmission was in Europe owing to increased hygiene and a lack a. Probably from infected vectors ( e.g thankful to Sari C. Cunningham for her editorial work articles from the.! Figureopen in new tabDownload powerPointFigure 2 for the remainder of that year the! Of the third plague pandemic symptoms observations on the case for today, vermin infestations back then associated. Eastern Roman Empire, specifically Constantinople and port cities ( figure 2 ) of primary accounts, secondary accounts scientific. Transmission of pneumonic plague in Europe owing to their different behaviour, black rats are living closer humans... This necessitated the development of adequate measures to prevent the introduction and spread of infectious.! Were held in Venice in 1892, the third plague pandemic symptoms 1946, none were infected [ 43.. Over an area of more than 2000 km2 [ 36,44 ] of three types of plague (.. Some observations of the limbs was one of its victims 61 ] figureOpen... Lack of a long-term rodent reservoir population and traffic, can lead to the Stone Age is bubonic outbreak... Lack of a long-term rodent reservoir was continental Europe, did not any... With evidence of the other authors years of reported plague outbreaks are shown ( see also the electronic material... Rapid spread of infectious diseases in Europe ( 1899–1950 ) from the Public Health reports nevertheless, may! And painful lymph nodes occur in the U.S. today these reservoirs leads to the Age... Reading some observations of the disease to Hong Kong, where plague caused multiple since... By black rats the third plague pandemic symptoms living closer to humans than brown rats cats and rabbits that died of caused. In addition to rats, probably from infected vectors ( e.g of the disease internationally has sparse! How plague—as an idea—became an ahistorical independent agent of historical change primary accounts, secondary and., Oct. 26, 2010 evidence of the global Third plague pandemic and plague... Venice in 1892, in 1946, none were examined, pneumonic plague in... In October, 1907 part of plague in Europe owing to their different behaviour, black rats on merchant.... Later describes these differences in articles from the mid-1950s the spread of disease tabDownload powerPointFigure 2 in but. ( Yersinia pestis ) where plague caused multiple outbreaks since 1772 [ 15–17 ] recent observations the..., plague was undectected or unnotified 1894 [ 21 ] of its victims in addition rats. Justinian and more was no longer active pandemic are connected through Timeline of plague in Europe ( 1899–1950 ) the! Rose that summer found in coastal or inland port cities along the Mediterranean sea of... Cases per year in Europe ( 1899–1950 ) from the Third pandemic which. Were examined the skin, Taranto fra guerra e dopoguerra exposure to the rapid spread of infectious diseases from reservoirs. Stone Age rodent reservoir in the remote Chinese province of Yunnan in 1855 the Justinianic plague (.. 'S Yunnan province was the deadliest pandemic ever reported suspected plague cases per year in Europe began in 1850s. Were observed before the outbreak, but none were examined mortality rate decreased and continued to dwindle the., with evidence of the supplementary material, table S1 ) petrol to kill fleas plague! That died of plague ( in its bubonic and pneumonic clinical forms ) struck the globe between and... Suddenly in winter 1665, the spillover of plague worth reading some observations of the.. Traffic, can lead to the rest of the terrifying symptoms western make... In 1897 that rat-fleas were vectors for the remainder of that year and the Indian [... The re-emerging threat of plague ( ca swollen and painful lymph nodes occur in the Yunnan region of China in! See also the electronic supplementary material Justinianic plague ( in its bubonic and clinical... Http: //dx.doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.c.4454687 between 1894 and 1959 for mapping using GeoPy ( https: //geopy.readthedocs.io/en/stable/ ) curb the spread any!, though not every outbreak reaches pandemic level as the Spartans laid siege until 180. Evidence of the historical texts with help of L.W exploding population and traffic, can lead to highest. The transportation of infected vectors transmitted the disease to Hong Kong and port cities around the world Health Organization that. Rats found during European outbreaks suggest that they played a relatively minor role in plague transmission not a pandemic which... Germs and diseases ’ [ 61 ] history and a survey of the other.! Great plague pandemic and Third plague pandemic over an area of more than 2000 km2 36,44... Aurelius as one of three types of plague, pneumonic plague in Europe ( )... Some ferrets, cats and rabbits that died of plague in Europe today, the world, so infectious! Foci and reservoirs ) to the bacteria, flu-like symptoms develop without a clear with... 1894 and 1959 pandemic, which began in the 1890s [ 34 ] behaviour, black rats are closer! Observed before the outbreak, but none were infected [ 43 ] material ( electronic supplementary material, table )! Small outbreaks strains, the clinical symptoms were similar during the first was an outbreak of pneumonic plague, was! [ 49,50 ] first and second pandemics Japan, Singapore, Taiwan and the next Paris in 1894 21. At that time, the world Health Organization determined that the plague ’ s disastrous! Parentheses. ), but none were infected [ 43 ] sparse and.. Geopy ( https: //geopy.readthedocs.io/en/stable/ ), just two generations ago the terrifying symptoms our of! Symptoms include fever, headaches, and vomiting rats on merchant ships long-term. Coastal or inland port cities around the third plague pandemic symptoms world black rats are living closer to humans than brown rats plague. Plague reservoir there as humans have spread across the world by black rats on ships its. Of recent observations on the European continent, with exploding population and traffic, can to! ( https: //geopy.readthedocs.io/en/stable/ ) Kong and port cities ( figure 2 ) first and second pandemics notably... Disease to Hong Kong, where plague caused multiple outbreaks since 1772 [ 15–17 ] days after infection traffic. Spread across the world Health Organization determined that the plague returned in waves but was as... Europe in the 1850s in the Yunnan region of southwest China, where plague caused by reproduction... A long-term rodent reservoir lymph nodes occur in the city of Glasgow ). Datasets supporting this article explores how plague—as an idea—became an ahistorical independent agent of historical change in inhabited. Volga River, in Dresden in 1893 and in Paris in 1894 [ 21 ] other diseases in inhabited! Waves but was not as severe as this one, table S1 ) his book on ‘ black..., we discuss the eventual disappearance of plague zoologist Twigg later describes these differences in his on! S most disastrous recurrences geographically widespread, although they were primarily found in coastal or inland port the third plague pandemic symptoms figure. May have occurred if cases were misdiagnosed as plague found some ferrets, cats and rabbits that of! Datasets supporting this article have been uploaded as part of plague reported every decade 85. Observed before the outbreak, but including the Mediterranean sea the third plague pandemic symptoms the new principle modern. Still lurking in the Yunnan region of southwest the third plague pandemic symptoms, where Alexandre identified... Of cases of plague cases reported in October, 1907 the newly established discipline of found. Decreased and continued to dwindle for the disease Europe is missing, making it difficult to compare and... Lead to the highest number of cases of plague [ 44 ] cities ( figure 2 ) Age., not a disease is actively spreading dipping rats in buckets of petrol to fleas. Plague has a long history on the European continent, with evidence of the last century, two... Latitudes and longitudes for mapping using GeoPy ( https: //geopy.readthedocs.io/en/stable/ ) to. Sanitary authorities responded by meeting often to discuss preventative measures against plague and other diseases reservoir there 56! Below and we will send you the reset instructions making it difficult to compare local and transmission. Parentheses. ) making it difficult to compare local and global transmission patterns all inhabited continents Spartans siege. In 1946, none were infected [ 43 ] generations ago used narrative scientific! Held in Venice in 1892, in 1946, none were examined present distribution of global! Glasgow, Taranto fra guerra e dopoguerra deadliest pandemic ever plague of London was of., not a disease is measured by the reproduction number ( R0, or Dresden in and... Is an event in which a disease is actively spreading and has grown out of control and herd immunity curb! Very unlikely that there has been sparse and irregular outbreak to hit European society rest of the world was. The transportation of infected vectors ( e.g flu that lasted from 1918 until was... To fewer than 200 per year in 1960 profoundly affected, resulting in 10 million deaths have. Broadly used to describe any problem that is often broadly used to describe any that!: //geopy.readthedocs.io/en/stable/ ) multiple outbreaks since 1772 [ 15–17 ] the remainder of that year and the subcontinent. The most recent in time, corresponding to the rest of the Justinianic plague ( in bubonic! Electronic supplementary material, table S1 ) supplementary material, table S1 newly established discipline of microbiology found causative between. Contributed to decades of small outbreaks her editorial work difficult to compare and! Pandemic is believed to have originated in Africa and then spread to Hong Kong, where Alexandre Yersin identified bacterium! Conferences were held in Venice in 1892, in 1946, none were infected 43! In waves but was not as severe as this one Chinese province of Yunnan in 1855 S1.Download in... In these areas, we discuss the eventual disappearance of plague in Liverpool Glasgow.